‘Master Of Roster’ Controversy In Kerala HC With Post-Retirement Revelations Of Justice Kemal Pasha

to have actually shown more care while making the roster change. The untimely lineup change planted seeds of doubt in public mind, and was bestprevented. He clarified that he does not share the sensation that the Chief Justice was acting with beneficial interests while making the lineup modification. Justice Pasha added that the Chief Justice ought to have foreseen that the roster modification at that juncture would be seen negatively by the general public, resulting in damage to the track record of the institution. Such unusual modifications may give factors for the general public to suspect external interference in justice administration and that hurt him.In his< a href =http://www.livelaw.in/judges-appointment-not-a-family-property-to-be-partitioned-kemal-pasha-j-slams-kerala-hc-collegium-in-his-farewell-speech/ target =_ blank rel=noopener >

goodbye speech, Justice Pasha had actually mentioned that certain"extra judicial forces"were creating difficulties in justice administration, and that judiciary was facing attacks from within and without.Chief Justice Dominic might have avoided Cardinal's case.Justice Pasha specified in Mathrubhumi news that it would have been much better if Chief Justice Antony Dominic had actually avoided hearing the appeal of Cardinal Alencherry. Pasha made the remark in response to a question

whether it appertained on part of Chief Justice Dominic to hear the Cardinal's appeal, as Justice Dominic belonged to Syro Malabar Church, of which the Cardinal was the head. The appeal considered by the Department Bench presided by Chief Justice Dominic was eventually allowed, reserving the instructions of Justice Pasha to register FIR against the Cardinal and some other priests in the Syro-Malabar Church land scam. Justice Pasha observed that unneeded debates might have been prevented if Chief Justice Dominic had referred the interest some other bench. He stated that it was important that justice is seen to be done.On political murders.In the Mathrubhoomi interview, he revealed his distress at the pattern of eliminating politics rivals."That is not genuine politics", he stated. He was reacting to questions about his judgments in Ariyil Shukoor case(where he bought CBI enquiry in a political murder allegedly carried out by CPI( M) employees), Kathiroor Manoj case (where difficulty of CPI(M)leader P.Jayarajan against UAPA charges was dismissed )and Congress worker Shuhaib murder case. He likewise lamented names from the media, and included that he had no occasion to see the faces of a few of the legal representatives who have actually been suggested for elevation. In his< a href=http://www.livelaw.in/judges-appointment-not-a-family-property-to-be-partitioned-kemal-pasha-j-slams-kerala-hc-collegium-in-his-farewell-speech/ target=_ blank rel =noopener > farewell speech on the celebration of his retirement on Might 24, Justice Pasha had actually observed that"judgeship was not a family home to be partitioned", which it ought to not be allotted on the lines of faith and caste.Recently a single Judge of the High Court has dismissed a petitionfiled by 2 attorneys challenging the High Court's suggestion to Supreme Court Collegium to elevate five lawyers as judges of the high court. It was alleged in the petition that the names of lawyers who are the kith and kin of the siting and/or retired or previous judges of the court or Supporter General, were proposed by the High Court Collegium.He likewise stated that the trend of judges accepting post-retirement task assignments from the government will ruin public self-confidence in the impartiality of judges."Have acted just according to my conscience", Chief Justice Dominc reacts; Justice

Ravindran terms post retirement revelations"petty"Chief Justice Antony Dominic, while speaking at a farewell function organized by the staff of the High Court, stated that he has actually acted only based on his conscience which he was setting his office with that fulfillment. Justice P.N Ravindran, the second senior judge of the High Court and member of Collegium, responded really greatly to the advancements."We need to withstand the efforts of minor individuals who taint the track record of this excellent organization after retirement" "Justice Ravindran stated in the goodbye meeting arranged by the personnel, by referring to the discoveries made by Justice Pasha. Justice Ravindran said that he will comment more about it on his speech throughout the complete court referral on his retirement on Monday, May 28. The controversy is likely to snowball if Justice Ravindran makes even more sharp responses on the concern on his official retirement speech.Chief Justice Dominic is retiring on May 30,

and Justice P.N Ravindran on May 29.



Language »